DIY Sealcoating vs. Hiring a Pro: What You Should Know

If your asphalt driveway is starting to look a little worn or faded, sealcoating might be just what it needs. A fresh sealcoat can protect your pavement from water damage, UV rays, oil spills, and general wear and tear. The question is—should you tackle the job yourself or call in a professional?

Let’s break down the pros and cons of DIY sealcoating vs. hiring a professional paving contractor, so you can make the best decision for your property, your time, and your budget.

What Is Sealcoating, Anyway?

Sealcoating is the process of applying a protective coating to an asphalt surface to extend its life and keep it looking clean and fresh. It acts like sunscreen for your driveway—shielding it from sun, rain, chemicals, and oxidation.

For most driveways, sealcoating is recommended every 2–3 years, depending on weather conditions and how much traffic the surface gets.

Option 1: DIY Sealcoating

Pros:

• Cost Savings (Maybe): On the surface, DIY can seem cheaper. Sealcoating kits or buckets from home improvement stores typically cost less than hiring a contractor.

• Weekend Project Appeal: If you enjoy hands-on work and don't mind getting messy, it could be a satisfying task to tackle yourself.

• Scheduling Control: You get to choose exactly when you do the work—no need to coordinate with a crew.

Cons:

• Inconsistent Results: Uneven application, streaks, or missed spots are common issues with DIY jobs. And a bad application can do more harm than good.

• Time-Consuming: Between cleaning, prepping, and applying (sometimes multiple coats), the process can take a full weekend or more—and that’s if the weather cooperates.

• Quality of Materials: Store-bought sealers are often lower quality than what the pros use. They might not last as long or offer the same level of protection.

• Equipment Limitations: You’ll need tools like squeegees, blowers, crack fillers, and safety gear. Buying or renting equipment adds to your cost—and learning to use them takes time.

Option 2: Hiring a Professional Sealcoating Company

Pros:

• Expert Results: Professionals have the experience, tools, and technique to apply the sealcoat evenly and effectively. No streaks, no mess.

• Better Materials: Commercial-grade sealers last longer and provide better protection than most DIY products.

• Time-Saving: A pro crew can prep and seal your driveway in a fraction of the time—often within a single day.

• Long-Term Value: A proper sealcoat applied by a pro can last longer, reducing the need for repairs or early repaving down the road.

Cons:

• Higher Upfront Cost: Hiring a professional will cost more than a DIY kit—but you're paying for quality, speed, and peace of mind.

• Scheduling Availability: Depending on the season, contractors may be booked up, so you might need to plan ahead.

So, Which Is Right for You?

If you’re on a tight budget, have a very small driveway, and don’t mind putting in some elbow grease, DIY sealcoating might work—as long as you're okay with a potentially shorter lifespan and more visible imperfections.

However, if you're looking for a longer-lasting, more professional-looking finish, hiring a pro is typically the better investment—especially for larger driveways or commercial lots. The job gets done faster, cleaner, and with results you can count on.

Sealcoating is one of the easiest ways to protect and extend the life of your asphalt surface—but only when done right. Whether you decide to do it yourself or call in the pros, just make sure you don’t skip this important maintenance step altogether.

Thinking about sealcoating your driveway or parking lot? At Hicks Paving, we use commercial-grade products, expert techniques, and years of experience to get the job done right the first time. Get in touch today for a free estimate!